Finally, a new episode of Doctor Who, the first one, not counting Christmas specials, since 2015. “The Pilot” sees the return of Peter Capaldi as the Twelfth Doctor, the best incarnation of the Doctor since the 2005 relaunch, with a story based on Echo and Narcissus—kind of an odd coincidence not long after I’d read a Sirenia Digest story based on Ovid’s tale of Narcissus, the man obsessed with looking at his own reflection, and the nymph who loved him, Echo, who could only speak in repetitions of what another person said. The episode gives us a very sweet version of the story but I would have liked the relationship between Bill and Heather developed more. Though by itself it works well as a sort of metaphor for a longer relationship, the danger of Bill getting attached to the reflection like someone obsessed with a relationship. I’m a bit annoyed that apparently no-one else liked how last season was composed entirely of two part episodes—that was a big improvement to my mind. Oh well.
Of course, another big thing with this new episode, something everyone’s really excited about, is the Doctor’s new companion—Matt Lucas as Nardole!
Okay, no-one really seems to care one way or another about Nardole. I thought he was a nice, amusing, not too obtrusive presence, there offering some funny reactions to instructions and info. So thumbs up, Matt Lucas.
And I thought Pearl Mackie was really good as Bill. I like how she dresses like a gymnast from the 80s. There’s something kind of Mork and Mindy-ish about her attire too.
In addition to the nice reworking of Echo and Narcissus, the reflection thing was of the nicely subtly weird variety. It’s kind of become standard, these stories about things that seem slightly off-kilter in the world ending up having an alien explanation, and maybe they are getting a little tired. Though the new companion learning the basic details of the TARDIS and the Doctor also had the feeling of a well worn song and dance at this point, too. I do like Steven Moffat and I liked this episode but I left it feeling, yeah, it’s time for some new blood.
It was nice they went to Australia. Though it reminds me, is anything happening with Peter Jackson (I know, he’s a Kiwi, not Australian) directing an episode? There was that clip of him with Capaldi and a Dalek and then nothing. What gives?
I like the idea of the Doctor being a university professor for 50 years. I wonder if it’s Steven Moffat subtly suggesting that Class isn’t canon—I’d be whole heartedly in support of that.